UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT …

                         UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
                          DISTRICT OF MASSACHUSETTS


MASSACHUSETTS BAY
TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY                     Civil Action No. 08-11364-GAO

                       Plaintiff
v.

ZACK ANDERSON, RJ RYAN,
ALESSANDRO CHIESA and the
MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF
TECHNOLOGY

                       Defendants


                              NOTICE OF APPEARANCE

          PLEASE TAKE NOTICE of the appearance of Emily Berger as co-counsel for

the defendants Zack Ryan, RJ Ryan, and Alessandro Chiesa in the above-captioned

action.

                                     DEFENDANTS ANDERSON, RYAN
                                       AND CHIESA

                                     By their attorneys,

Dated: August 12, 2008               /s/ Emily A. Berger
                                     Emily A. Berger, BBO No. 650,841
                                     emily@eff.org
                                     Jennifer Stisa Granick, CA Bar No. 168423
                                     Jennifer@eff.org
                                     Kurt Opsahl, CA Bar No. 191303
                                     kurt@eff.org
                                     Marcia Hofmann, CA Bar No. 250087
                                     marcia@eff.org
                                     ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
                                     454 Shotwell St.
                                     San Francisco, CA 94110
                                     (415) 436-9333
                                     (415) 436-9993 (fax)