Tags: appointees, building science, collapse of world trade center, construction safety, dear mr, dtap, fire research laboratory, national construction, national institute of standards, national institute of standards and technology, nibs, nist staff, public teleconference, safety team, secretary of commerce, september 11 2001, standards organizations, standards technology, team investigation, technical assistance program,
National Construction Safety Team Advisory Committee
National Institute of Standards & Technology
The Honorable Carlos M. Guttierez
Secretary of Commerce
Washington, DC 20230
Dear Mr. Secretary:
I am pleased to submit the 2006 Annual Report of the National Construction Safety Team Advisory
Committee (NCSTAC) of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). The Committee
serves as NIST's advisor on implementation of the National Construction Safety Team (NCST) Act
(P.L. 107-231) and our report reflects our views as an independent, private sector body. Because no
new NCST investigations were undertaken in 2006, this letter report constitutes our entire report for this
year.
The Committee met once during 2006 by public teleconference to review the progress to date on the
Dissemination and Technical Assistance Program (DTAP) and the proposed plans for continuing the
investigation of the collapse of World Trade Center 7 (WTC 7), the third building involved in the
September 11, 2001 disaster and to receive comments from the public on the content of the Committee's
2006 Report to Congress.
Two Committee members resigned during the year reducing membership to seven individuals. In
discussion with the then-Director of the Building and Fire Research Laboratory (BFRL), the Chair
agreed that new appointees would not be considered until after the completion of the WTC 7
investigation and/or the beginning of a new safety team investigation where specific technical expertise
was required. All other Committee members whose terms were expiring accepted reappointment.
The investigation of the collapse of the two towers, WTC 1 and WTC 2, were completed and presented
to the public in the late summer of 2005. Since then, in accordance with the plans developed three years
ago under DTAP, NIST staff have been working with various public sector Codes and Standards
organizations and the National Institute of Building Science (NIBS) in affecting construction changes in
the nation's building codes and architectural and structural engineering practice groups.
The Committee believes that the NCST Act's unique features such as subpoena power, open
communication with the engineering and architectural communities during an investigation and the
commitment to support the development of improved Codes and Standards through DTAP provide a
powerful public service. Although not used in the WTC or Station nightclub investigations (for different
reasons), subpoena power can provide NIST leverage in conducting safety team investigations where
litigation or political concerns might prevent access to the disaster site or to necessary forensic evidence
and witnesses. Perhaps more significantly, Safety Team investigations to date have stirred early, open
public discussions on both the WTC and Station investigations. Many improvements were made to
National Construction Safety Team Advisory Committee
National Institute of Standards and Technology
existing codes and standards even before the investigations were concluded. Subsequent to the release
of the final investigation reports, wide-ranging reviews have been undertaken of significant engineering,
architectural, safety and fire protection practices with promising results.
The Committee remains concerned that several of the recommendations made in its previous Reports to
Congress for permanent funding for Safety Team investigations has not been acted on. The Committee
re-affirms its opinion that NIST cannot effectively implement its role under the Act unless Congress and
the Administration establish sustained support. The Committee strongly believes sustained funding is
justified given the proven impact and actions the private sector has undertaken as a direct result of NIST
findings of the WTC Tower and Station nightclub investigations and urges Congress to provide such
support in FY 2007.
Sincerely,
Paul M. Fitzgerald, Chair
National Construction Safety Team Advisory Committee
John M. Barsom, Member
Robert D. Hanson, Member
Forman A. Williams, Member
Committee Members Not Participating in the Drafting of this Report
David S. Collins, Member
Kathleen J. Tierney, Member
Charles Thornton, Member
cc: D. Sampson
R. Cresanti
W. Jeffrey
S. Sunder (DFO)
2